#5805 - 12/05/04 11:54 AM
Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
Spyrios
UGN Member
|
UGN Member
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
VA
|
World War III has erupted. Twenty-six people have arrived at your bomb shelter that has room for only ten people. You must decide who will be allowed to enter the shelter. These people will stay in the shelter for three months. You must select 5 males and 5 females. When the shelter reopens, they may be the last humans on Earth. The future of the world may depend upon your decisions. Make sure that skills are not duplicated to make the most effective group of 10.
MALES Historian College Professor Janitor Football Player Accountant Shop Teacher Manager at McDonald’s 8-Year-Old Child Musician Scientist Preacher Naval Officer Policeman with Gun
FEMALES Secretary High School Cheerleader Sales Executive Truck Driver Teacher Chef Artist 8 Year Old Child Architect Psychiatrist Air Force Pilot Grandma Housewife (6 months pregnant)
This is a critical thinking assignment for me and thought it would be fun here since i haven't seen a good debate in awhile.
D, world destruction Over and overture N, do I need Apostrophe T, need this torture?-They Might Be Giants
|
|
|
#5806 - 12/05/04 12:11 PM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,202
Gremelin
Community Owner
|
Community Owner

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,202
Likes: 11
Portland, OR; USA
|
|
|
|
#5807 - 12/05/04 12:23 PM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 1,146
Ice
UGN News Staff
|
UGN News Staff

Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 1,146
Likes: 1
Canada
|
LOL, and no Ice  Comon  Thats a little tuffy, dont feel like picking lol.
Good artists copy, great artists steal.
-Picasso
|
|
|
#5808 - 12/05/04 12:27 PM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
Spyrios
UGN Member
|
UGN Member
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
VA
|
giz manager at mcdonalds was there, lol
D, world destruction Over and overture N, do I need Apostrophe T, need this torture?-They Might Be Giants
|
|
|
#5809 - 12/05/04 12:37 PM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,202
Gremelin
Community Owner
|
Community Owner

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,202
Likes: 11
Portland, OR; USA
|
Well, can't have a preacher and an 8yo in the same place, so I decided that we'd need a man of the cloth... Another tossup was the teacher or the Archetict, but the archetict won... Mainly because we had a college professor in the other group... Standings: MALESHistorian - Someone who knows the past, what other reason? College Professor - He should know his [censored], or he'll be voted off the island Musician - Music is the gateway to the soul Scientist - if I need some meth, who else do i need to turn to in the group? Preacher FEMALESSecretary - We can get a little "you want a raise" action High School Cheerleader - She'd be a HS student, thus young and able to be able to have a longer lifeline after the incodent (theoretically) Chef - We need someone to cook don't we? Artist - Art, art, and more art! Art of the destruction mainly  ... Architect - We'll probably need to rebuild no?
|
|
|
#5810 - 12/05/04 12:56 PM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
Spyrios
UGN Member
|
UGN Member
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
VA
|
I picked shop teacher as builder though, cause a shop teacher could build a shelter and not care about esthetics
D, world destruction Over and overture N, do I need Apostrophe T, need this torture?-They Might Be Giants
|
|
|
#5812 - 12/05/04 09:14 PM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
Spyrios
UGN Member
|
UGN Member
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
VA
|
true, why not the 6 month pregnant lady? 2 lives in one?
D, world destruction Over and overture N, do I need Apostrophe T, need this torture?-They Might Be Giants
|
|
|
#5814 - 12/05/04 11:19 PM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
Spyrios
UGN Member
|
UGN Member
Joined: Mar 2004
Posts: 419
VA
|
Why? And You can't duplicate skills so if you have one 8 year old you can't have the other. I would pick the 8 year old girl over the boy if anything because the men can continue to reproduce a lot longer than women can, there fore the 8 year old girl when mature can help repopulate more than the boy child can. Also Remember This could be the satrt of a whole new world we are talking about, so emotion should play no part in it. It should be the best for the human race not just for your feelings.
D, world destruction Over and overture N, do I need Apostrophe T, need this torture?-They Might Be Giants
|
|
|
#5817 - 12/06/04 08:31 AM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 524
dashocker
Member
|
Member
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 524
Cornfields everywhere...
|
Interesting....very interesting.
MALES:
Football player (strong, manual labor, follows orders) Shop teacher (practical, can build stuff, patient leader) Musician (creative, people need music) Scientist (would be necessary for a new world) Manager @ McDonald's (leader, manangerial skills but without authority complex)
FEMALES:
Artist (creative, people need art) Housewife (6 months pregnant) (2 lives in 1, motherly role) Air Force Pilot (navigation and transportation, follows orders) Architect (knows how to build stuff) High School Cheerleader (young, fertile, can survive without assistance unlike a child)
My first thought was of survival as opposed to rebuilding a new world. You should think about the group dynamic. Can't have too many leaders or too many followers. Chose those who wouldn't conflict (a preacher and a scientist might not be good, which is more practical?).
Good topic.
(PS, why no doctor?)
|
|
|
#5818 - 12/06/04 09:46 AM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 384
Defcon
Ass Clown
|
Ass Clown

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 384
508 or 207
|
If there were 10 people that were going to start over, wouldn't there be severe inbreding after the first few generations? If the human race ended up like Appilacian Hicks, I'd rather they'd die out and the lizard mutants take over.
But anyway, here's who I'd pick: Males: Historian, someone's gotta have a record of the past to know where we came from. Scientist, depending on the field, can keep the sciences and development going and possibly medical stuff if they are trained as such. Naval Officer, key leadership role, plus has nautical and military skills. Also can tie knots. Shop Teacher, builder and craftsman, also capable of doing maintainace of the bomb shelter. Preacher, this is more of a moral choice, faith can get people through tough times and can also be a councelor/confidant for people in the new era.
Females: High School Cheerleader, what can I say, I have a lolita complex. Artist, the world needs creativity and badass tribal designs. Chef, food preperation and sanitation, food = morale. Housewife with child, 2 lives in one, plus the child will easily adapt and be socialized in the new world. Housewife would be capable of acting as a midwife for future children later down the road. Teacher, only if she's a hottie or a milf, someone has to be able to teach the younger generations.
There we go, my list of people to restart the world.
"Remember how much fun you had shooting spitwads at the teacher in seventh grade? Imagine applying that kind of attitude to actually [censored] with Mitsubishi!" - Jello Biafra
|
|
|
#5821 - 12/07/04 12:07 AM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 3,255
§intå×
|

Joined: Dec 2002
Posts: 3,255
Likes: 3
Maryland
|
MALES Football Player - Strength and good DNA most likely. This is why many women are atracted to muscle, it usally means good breading Scientist - This is brains, someone who can see things through if they went to collage 6 to 8 years. Could help with radiation poisioning Naval Officer - Best of both worlds, brains and he is fit. Naval officers I am assuming young one here, are smart, fit men. This is good for breeding. College Professor - Brain power for bloodlines, also might have some smarts as to how to re-build. Musician - Need some sort of art to pass on. a song for people to get behind and focus on and not thier pain and suffering.
FEMALES High School Cheerleader - Young fit and ready to birth. Teacher - Brain power to help come up with plans and filter into DNA pool Architect - Re-building and someone who can see things through Air Force Pilot - Same as Naval Officer Housewife - She has new life. This will be born in 3 months then she can do it again. We know she is working up till now. No Guarentee on the others.
The kids, I am sorry to say, bring nothing to the table but chaos, and fear for them. Grant it the wife will fear for her un-born baby, but no one else can see or hear it's cries yet. This could make a big difference in 3 months in the tank
|
|
|
#5824 - 12/07/04 07:52 AM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 384
Defcon
Ass Clown
|
Ass Clown

Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 384
508 or 207
|
Atleast some of us we can agree with our choices, but obviously there are a lot of people in the group that are pretty much useless anyway you look at it.
Policeman with Gun, whoopty [censored] doo, the cop has a pistol. Do you really want one guy armed in the bunker for 3 months, 3 months is a long time to be in close quarters with 11 people (10 people plus you) do we really need to factor in a gun. Plus pistols pretty much suck when it comes to protection and hunting.
Truck Driver, yup driving a truck is one hell of a skill for being in a bunker for 3 months. When you do emerge, how the hell do you even know if any trucks actually survived. What about fuel and logistics, pretty much screw this person.
8 year old kids, probably couldn't handle being in the bunker for three months. Emotional and mental trauma will probably make functioning in the new society difficult. Kids are high a lot of work and use up a lot of resources while bringing absolutely nothing to the table. More or less a liability and have a low chance of survival after the bunker opens.
Grandmother, old, senile, past her prime reproduction wise, like the children she has a low rate of survival and really a liability. You've lived a long life granny, why not take one for the team.
"Remember how much fun you had shooting spitwads at the teacher in seventh grade? Imagine applying that kind of attitude to actually [censored] with Mitsubishi!" - Jello Biafra
|
|
|
#5829 - 12/07/04 08:46 AM
Re: Play God
|
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,202
Gremelin
Community Owner
|
Community Owner

Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 7,202
Likes: 11
Portland, OR; USA
|
Originally posted by Defcon: Atleast some of us we can agree with our choices, but obviously there are a lot of people in the group that are pretty much useless anyway you look at it.
Policeman with Gun, whoopty [censored] doo, the cop has a pistol. Do you really want one guy armed in the bunker for 3 months, 3 months is a long time to be in close quarters with 11 people (10 people plus you) do we really need to factor in a gun. Plus pistols pretty much suck when it comes to protection and hunting.
Truck Driver, yup driving a truck is one hell of a skill for being in a bunker for 3 months. When you do emerge, how the hell do you even know if any trucks actually survived. What about fuel and logistics, pretty much screw this person.
8 year old kids, probably couldn't handle being in the bunker for three months. Emotional and mental trauma will probably make functioning in the new society difficult. Kids are high a lot of work and use up a lot of resources while bringing absolutely nothing to the table. More or less a liability and have a low chance of survival after the bunker opens.
Grandmother, old, senile, past her prime reproduction wise, like the children she has a low rate of survival and really a liability. You've lived a long life granny, why not take one for the team. That's what I based my assessments on  ...
|
|
|
|
Forums41
Topics33,701
Posts68,795
Average Daily Posts0
|
Members2,173
Most Online1,567 Apr 25th, 2010
|
|
|
Okay WTF?
by HenryMiring on 09/27/17 08:45 AM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|