I'm not too demanding, really. Personality is very big in my book, and I'd like to be with a girl who is sweet, and kind, and an absolute must: a girl who is sincere. Insincere people are my #1 personal pet peeve, so obviously I'd like to be with a girl who is sincere in her feelings. As for looks, I side with SR when I say I'd like the girl I'm with to be proportional, and definitely have a cute face. I knew a girl my freshman year in college who was nice, but had this conceited attitude. No way would I date her. Another thing: One of the first things I notice about a girl from up close is her eyes. If she can maintain eye contact with me, that'll get the ball rolling. If she can't even look me in the eye, usually it's time to move on...
(And yes I know the question was not on personality, so don't try to point that out to me.
)